Asset Composition (40%)
v4.1 asset methodology: category-specific dimensions, evidence-backed scoring, cap cascade, hard-fail controls, and staleness penalties.
Asset quality is the irreducible risk floor. The v4.1 asset model scores assets by category and then applies non-compensatory caps.
1) Category Taxonomy
| Category | Examples | Primary failure mode |
|---|---|---|
| native | ETH, WETH | Chain halt / liveness failure |
| fiat_backed_stablecoin | USDC, USDT, PYUSD | Issuer insolvency, reserve shortfall |
| cdp_stablecoin | DAI, USDS, LUSD, GHO | Collateral cascade, governance attack |
| synthetic_stablecoin | USDe, USD0, eUSD | Basis unwind, funding inversion |
| lst | wstETH, cbETH, rETH | Slashing and withdrawal risk |
| lrt | weETH, ezETH, rsETH | AVS/slashing aggregation risk |
| wrapped_btc | WBTC, cbBTC, tBTC | Bridge/custodian failure |
| governance_token | LINK, UNI, ARB | Volatility and liquidity shock |
| unreviewed | Any unclassified asset | Unknown / insufficient assessment |
2) Dimension-Based Scoring
The weighted formula depends on category. Core dimensions include:
peg_stabilityissuer_custodyredeemabilityreserve_transparencygovernance_controlsprotocol_securityoperator_qualitybridge_mechanismdependency_depthliquidityvolatility
Dimension weights are defined in the active methodology configuration.
3) Cap Cascade (Non-Compensatory)
Final asset score is the minimum of weighted score and all active caps.
final_asset_score = min(
weighted_dimension_score,
overlay_cap,
review_status_cap,
hard_fail_cap,
override_cap,
staleness_cap
)Review status caps
reviewed-> 10.0provisional-> 9.0unreviewed-> 8.0
For provisional or missing evidence contexts, default dimension fallback is conservative (2.5).
4) Overlays
yield_bearing: score constrained by wrapper/underlying dependency.lockup: liquidity dimension is down-weighted.
5) Hard-Fail Controls
Hard-fail flags apply strict caps regardless of weighted dimension quality.
All flags:
sanctions_exposure-> cap 0.0active_depeg-> cap 1.0 (7-day cooldown)redemption_paused-> cap 2.0 (3-day cooldown)single_signer_upgrade-> cap 3.0endogenous_collateral_high-> cap 4.0 (14-day cooldown)proof_of_reserve_missing-> cap 4.0 (30-day cooldown)unaudited_token_contract-> cap 4.0no_recent_attestation-> cap 5.0 (30-day cooldown)
Flags are event-sourced and may include trigger windows/cooldowns.
6) Staleness Penalties
Evidence freshness affects effective dimension values:
- stale (
now > fresh_until) -> value x 0.92 - expired (
now > fresh_until + 90d) -> value reduced to 75% with a minimum floor of 5.0 - if stale/expired weighted share exceeds threshold, a global staleness cap applies
7) Unresolved Address Fallback
If an adapter cannot resolve an exposure address, scoring falls back to strict unreviewed behavior:
- asset score constrained to conservative low cap
- explainability includes machine-readable unresolved-address reason
8) Portfolio-Level Adjustments
After per-exposure asset scoring, portfolio penalties are applied at vault level:
- concentration penalty
- category correlation penalty
- wrong-way risk penalty
These adjustments prevent concentrated portfolios from appearing safer than diversified equivalents with similar average exposure quality. Single-asset vaults are exempt from concentration and correlation penalties.
Risk Framework v4.1
How Philidor scores DeFi vaults 0-10 using a 3-vector model with v4.1 asset methodology, explainability, and model governance controls.
Platform & Strategy (40%)
Protocol and strategy resilience vector: maturity, audit depth, strategy complexity, dependency factors, and incident caps.